The aims are honourable enough: to achieve global solutions with local nuance and gain alignment on the way. And that might just be the outcome were it not for…
Truth #2. Modern marketers don’t stay anywhere long. The average tenure on a brand varies according to geography and specific role (see panel), but it is typically somewhere between 18 and 24 months.
Marketers are always looking to move onward and upward, and the time they take to make that next big step is shrinking. In the US, according to an annual study by executive search consultants Spencer Stuart, the average tenure of chief marketers dropped in 2015 for the first time in a decade.
In the UK, The Marketing Society reports that chief marketers tend to seek new pastures after an average of just 18 months. For digital marketing professionals, that time is even shorter at around 12 months, according to the Mondo study The Future of Digital Marketing.
Speaking at an event in 2015, Bartle Bogle Hegarty co-founder Sir John Hegarty reckoned he was "lucky" if a marketer client was still in place on one of his agency’s accounts after 18 months – "And that is having a detrimental effect," he added, "no doubt about it."
Now, put those truths together. Probability dictates that, at some point between the beginning and the end of a task-force initiative, a team member will leave and a new one will join. So it’s goodbye Kim Su – who has done an excellent job – and it’s hello Xavier in her place.
The muddle becomes inevitable when you look at things from Xavier’s point of view. Even if it’s an internal appointment, he might have had to clear six or seven interviews to get the role. He will be aware of his predecessor’s reputation. Will he be content to just sit there quietly on the conference calls and in the workshops, demurring to the team’s longer input? No: he’ll be eager to make his mark.
How exactly he’ll do that will depend on how far in the initiative has got. If it’s somewhere around the middle, with views and ideas crystallising, Xavier is likely to make his presence felt through the offer of some "fresh thinking".
That adjective – "fresh" – is meant as an automatic positive. But Xavier’s thinking could be freshly naïve, freshly shallow, freshly misjudged. If it came from another member of the team, the others would know how to defuse it. But fresh thinking from a fresh face is harder to parry. Muddle.
If it’s earlier in the process, and the team has just assigned tasks and agreed methodologies, Xavier might help by sharing "learnings" about process from initiatives he has been part of before. This skewers momentum just when it was getting going and throws the team into disarray. Muddle.
If Xavier joins towards completion, with ideas firmly down and arguments prepared, there is another typical ploy. He will offer to play "devil’s advocate" – simply take the opposite position from whatever is agreed. But the team isn’t looking for a devil right now; it is looking for cohesion. Muddle – and probably a missed deadline.
Of course, it is conceivable that any or all these interventions can be helpful. Xavier just might be a genius. More often, though, he is a normally competent person whose desire to hit the ground strutting has temporarily got the better of his judgment and humility.
What can we change here? We’re not going to change the system, much as some of us would like to, and we’re not going to change marketing’s revolving door. So we’ll try to change Xavier.
My friend, you’ve been hired because you’re good, so you can relax a little. True, you can’t sit on your hands forever, or you’ll be seen as inert ballast, but you could do well to "time" your contribution.
So give yourself a deadline: 30 days. Until then, do very little, brilliantly. Be positive. Be open. Get into the data. Ask questions, but strictly for clarity.
You will ensure that you really understand what the team has drawn together, and you will do them a favour by alerting them to their own little inaccuracies, should they struggle to provide clear answers.
After those 30 days are up, go ahead and make your mark in any way you see fit. You’ll probably find, though, that the urge has mellowed and your input will be quieter, deeper, cleverer and, well, less muddled.
You’ll be a lot less brittle, too, which is good for the soul. That isn’t another truth about marketing – just a truth about life.
(The author is former PPA business columnist of the year has a PhD in marketing, an MBA from London Business School and is a partner at Passionbrand. @helenedw)
(This article first appeared on CampaignLive.co.uk)