Dr AL Sharada
Mar 17, 2023

Creative critique from a gender lens: 6-10 March

Dr AL Sharada, director, Population First, reviews ads from last week on the basis of gender sensitivity

Creative critique from a gender lens: 6-10 March

What could have worked: 

 

Star Sports

It is disappointing that when women are actively participating in cricket in all roles- as players, fans, reporters and analysts, the IPL ad is so very male-centric.

 

Featuring a few women cricketers as well as promoting the game would have made the ad so much more inclusive.

 

Gender Sensitivity Score (GSS): 2.5/5

 

What did not work: 

 

Ads for financial and technical products and services often tend to be gender stereotypical as the ads featured this week show.

 

Aditya Birla Sunlife

The ad features a couple, a husband who is stressed out due to his financial responsibilities and concerns and a wife playing a supportive role. 

 

The ad is very stereotypical, like many ads on financial services. It reinforces the traditional gender roles of men as providers and women as supporters. It perpetuates the stereotype that men are primarily responsible for managing finances and financial planning, with the financial contributions of women and their ability to make financial decisions being ignored.

 

It is important to show an equitable partnership between couples with both being actively involved in making financial decisions and planning for their future. It would resonate better with the double income young couples, the target audience of the communication, who believe in gender equality. 

 

GSS: 2.5/5

 

Turtlemint

The Turtlemint ad also similarly reinforces the idea that men are more likely to be the financial advisers, that men are primarily responsible for financial planning and investment, with women being almost invisible in the communication.

 

GSS: 2.5/5

 

Scaler

 

Like financial services ads, technology-related ads also often sideline women and focus on men as the creators, promoters and users of technology. This scaler ad is no exception.

 

The ad features a male protagonist who is portrayed as a tech enthusiast who wants to advance his career. He is shown using Scaler, an e-learning platform that offers various tech courses to help him achieve his goals.

 

Not featuring any women in the ad perpetuates the gender stereotype that technology is a male domain.

 

Showing women using Scaler to advance their careers in technical fields would have conveyed a strong message to the viewers that it is natural for women to aspire for careers in STEM fields.

 

GSS: 2.5/5

 

Other films from the week:

 

Haldirams

GSS: 3/5

 

Vivel

GSS: 3.25/5

 

7Up

GSS: 3/5

 

Tetley

GSS: 3/5

Source:
Campaign India

Related Articles

Just Published

6 hours ago

BJP leads online political ad space with INR 19.1 ...

The ruling party has allocated over 117 crores to Google Ads since January for campaign purposes, according to the Google Ads Transparency Centre.

6 hours ago

Bisleri India on the hunt for a new creative partner

The pitch is currently underway via the brand's Mumbai office.

7 hours ago

Amazon layoffs impact APAC adtech and media leaders

The job cuts are part of Amazon's plans to streamline its sales, marketing and global services division globally.

8 hours ago

Advertisers are not fully prepared for the demise ...

The latest Future of Measurement report reveals that only 2% of advertisers are using a mix of MMM, experiments, and attribution, for measurement.