Dave Trott
Nov 07, 2017

Dave Trott's blog: When it's insane to be sane

The author cites an example of 'Confirmation Bias' from psychiatric hospitals and links it to the traditional versus digital advertising debate

Dave Trott's blog: When it's insane to be sane
In 1973, David Rosenhan was professor of psychology at Stanford University.
 
He worried about the low standards of diagnosis across America.
 
So he devised an experiment.
 
He and a group of volunteers got themselves admitted to 12 psychiatric hospitals.
 
Once inside they acted normally to see if they were correctly diagnosed as sane.
 
The hospitals ranged from rural to urban, from underfunded to private.
 
Besides Rosenhan, the volunteers included psychologists and psychiatrists.
 
To get admitted, they said they’d been having mild auditory hallucinations.
 
Once inside they reverted to normal behaviour, to see if staff noticed they were sane.
 
But not a single member of staff noticed they were sane.
 
Whatever they did, the staff interpreted their behaviour as insane.
 
When Rosenhan and the volunteers took notes, the staff reported it as "pathological writing behaviour".
 
When they queued early for lunch, the staff reported them "exhibiting oral-acquisition symptoms".
 
The staff refused to see their behaviour as sane.
 
Eventually a team of lawyers had to step in to get the volunteers released from the hospitals.
 
Even then, the staff wouldn’t certify them as sane, just "in remission".
 
No matter what the evidence, they would not accept the volunteers were sane.
 
These findings were reported in the journal Science.
 
But a famous teaching hospital said it would be impossible for their staff to be fooled.
 
So David Rosenhan issued a challenge.
 
They would see how many of his fake patients the hospital could spot over the next three months.
 
At the end of that period the hospital had vetted 118 patients.
 
They spotted 41 fakes, and another 42 suspects.
 
But David Rosenhan hadn’t sent a single fake patient along during that period.
 
So the hospital was classifying genuinely ill patients as sane.
 
Previously, the hospitals couldn’t spot sane people when they were looking for insane.
 
Now they kept spotting sane people where there weren’t any.
 
What we would call Confirmation Bias had taken over from the ability to think.
 
Confirmation Bias is when we can’t evaluate results objectively.
 
We can only use those results to confirm whatever findings we’re looking for.
 
Which is exactly what happens in marketing.
 
We can’t accept the results unless they confirm the answer we’ve already decided we want.
 
Recently, the answer we wanted was that online media was better than traditional media.
 
Whatever the evidence the other way, it was ignored as dinosaur thinking.
 
But finally, the evidence is beginning to get through to marketers.
 
Mark Pritchard, P&G’s chief brand officer, recently said that digital media was "murky at best and fraudulent at worst."
 
Because the evidence had become overwhelming, he said the following:
 
"We have come to our senses and will no longer accept publisher self-reporting without external verification."
 
Hopefully, we’ve begun thinking again instead of just operating on Confirmation Bias.
 
Because here’s where we have to question our sanity.
 
Most "creativity", most "marketing", has now been shifted to the media department.
 
Where most buying is done by programmatic.
 
So most advertising is now being done by algorithms.
 
(Dave Trott is the author of Creative Mischief, Predatory Thinking and One Plus One Equals Three. This article first appeared on CampaignLive.co.uk)
 
Source:
Campaign India

Follow us

Top news, insights and analysis every weekday

Sign up for Campaign Bulletins

Related Articles

Just Published

Premium
Publicis Groupe announces its Group Leadership Team for India, Sri Lanka
Premium
2 hours ago

Publicis Groupe announces its Group Leadership Team ...

This is another step in driving the group's 'power of one' strategy in this market

Premium
Lucky number: India, China rank number 13 on D&AD awards tally
Premium
22 hours ago

Lucky number: India, China rank number 13 on D&AD ...

India finishes with a total tally of nine Pencils in this year's awards

Premium
Republic TV hires What’s Your Problem as content creation partner
Premium
22 hours ago

Republic TV hires What’s Your Problem as content ...

The partnership will include creating advertiser funded programmes or branded content

Premium
Tata Sky and Netflix to join hands
Premium
1 day ago

Tata Sky and Netflix to join hands

The partners call it the next innovation in content delivery